Well that was…umm…yeah…
Testing to see if he could take away her source of power maybe?
And now he’s trying to demotivate or turn her, but Phin’s not about to fall so easily from a sudden shock…is she?
Even in fighting her, corrupted by the Tain, he seems hesitant to strike decisively. Part of his plan? Uncertainty because he doesn’t believe everything he’s saying about her? Or perhaps he really feels some tiny shred of sympathy for her perceived plight as another tool of Crow Gideon?
Darn it all, Aria! I normally don’t hypothesize so much about one webcomic, but you keep hanging us in suspenders with every fresh page and it’s starting to drive me nuts! 😉
Charidan
Given our understanding of how commanding works, it is possible that there simply do not exist attacks that really work on them. He just tried severing her star link, which sounds like a pretty ultimate attack. Other than that, what do you *do* to an entity which subjectively defines itself? It’s not like stabbing her actually has much effect. You have to go after her mind. Thus, probing questions.
Chromoid
You make a very compelling argument.
Aria
Comments like this are so encouraging heee. I really hope you guys like what I have planned!
Chromoid
I look forward to the eventual unravelling of the mysteries in this story!
Sandman366
So his plan was to cut her and Brokenspectre apart, but that can’t be done in this case?
(And she seems to be going a little like “What just happened what the HELL just happened WUT JUST HAPPENED” in…panel 3?)
Sounds like a little more Tain in there than just Raven compared to before, too.
Aria
Yep yep. Killing commanders is tough, but killing commanders with an angry deity attached is considerably harder. It was worth a shot~
I imagine it’s also a fairly disorienting thing to have done to you, hah
Sandman366
Would such an attack be expected to work in most cases, even on tougher opponents like Gideon, it just doesn’t work this time because they’re rooted far more together than, like, anyone should be expected to be?
Aria
That’s exactly it! If Hazard had tried that with someone like Gideon, who we’ve seen described as “wearing” his star like equipment, it would have probably worked. Theoretically at least. This method is probably the result of his research, so it’s also possible it hasn’t been tested much yet. But Phineas and Brokenspectre developed around each other so there’s not much to separate. It’s like the difference between pulling ivy off of a tree vs. trying to free a fence the tree grew around.
Sandman366
Well, I suppose it’s nice to know his better part of a century on trying to find a way to kill Gideon hasn’t been a complete waste of his time, he did have something to show for it….just keeps procrastinating anything more than theory.
Though from all accounts it sounds like he’d get stomped before he would even have the chance to try such a move on Crow.
A Wild Bird
Did he just attack her soul!!??
Oscar Crooks
Ah that’s, I didn’t think Gideon was the type for the living his dreams through his prodigy. He failed, so he’s tried to build a commander that can.
ALso that’s pretty interesting, i always assumed Commanders needed a star to command, but from reading these comments, and the fact that Hazard has a star, I think commanding, and tying yourself to a star are different practices. Phin always commands her energy from the environment around her, she doesn’t use broken-specters energy to command (as evidenced by the colour of the energy that emanates when she commands, Broken specter is golden yellow, while Phineas has commanded three different power-sources so far, The planet, that starstone in the mines and now Artemis; which are aquamarine, and two different shades of light blue respectively).
So why do the two commanders we’ve seen so far use stars? Phineas HAD to have hers attached or she would die. And according to Jocasta, the star keeps the host alive, effectively making the host immortal. And Crows Crew were fighting gods and stuff, So i assumed shoving celestial body’s in their skulls was an effort to level the playing field somewhat by making them immortal. But not aging is a pretty crappy defense against being crushed by giant monsters like Hastur. prompting the question, what do the stars actually do?
Our sun outputs 1.4 x 1031 joules every hour (for reference a one megaton atomic bomb releases 4.18 x 1015 joules on detonation. And our sun isn’t the biggest or anything, it’s about average compared to other stars). The stars in the various (noun for hollow people?) are going to be differently sized, But it’s safe to assume that they’re going to be outputting crazy amounts of power, (like, World-blowing-up-several-thosand-times-over-power). And Phineas definitely isn’t throwing around that kind of power, because it took her a significant amount of effort to move a large rock.
The only reason I can think of why stars don’t deliver more significant power to their hosts, is the Host’s limits. Having them transform so much energy would kill them, so it’s limited to an amount they can handle. The star allows the user to “cast magic” indefinitely because they’re connected to such a large power source, but the host needs rest and breaks because like any equipment, they’ll wear out from overuse.
This is just an theory though, I get the feeling there’s a bit more to it than this, because I’ve only considered the side of the host and not what benefit the star gains from this relationship. But this is already 3+ paragraphs long and that’s another wild rambling for another day.